Skip to main content

Publication Details

Phenomenal Concepts and Physical Facts: A Dialogue with Mary

(Original title: Phenomenal Concepts and Physical Facts: A Dialogue with Mary)
Filozofia, 74 (2019), 10, 797-807.
Type of work: Articles
Publication language: English

This is a dialogue between an opponent of the phenomenal concept strategy and Mary from Frank Jackson’s knowledge argument. In this dialogue, Mary, who has complete physical knowledge about what it is like to see red, but has never seen red, is a physicalist and she defends the phenomenal concept strategy against her interlocutor’s objections. In the end, none of them is able to convince the other, but their conversation, through considerations of different versions of the knowledge argument and different applications of the phenomenal concept strategy, reveals the most basic disagreement, or clash of intuitions, they have. The implied conclusion of the dialogue is that the disagreement on the success of phenomenal concept strategy as a physicalist response to the knowledge argument cannot be resolved unless this particular clash of intuitions is resolved.


Knowledge argument, Phenomenal concepts, Phenomenal knowledge, Physicalism

File to download: PDF